SUNRISE, FL - OCTOBER 15: Goaltender Mathieu Garon #32 of the Tampa Bay Lightning stops a shot by David Booth #10 of the Florida Panthers on October 15, 2011 at the BankAtlantic Center in Sunrise, Florida. (Photo by Joel Auerbach/Getty Images)
To say there has been a lot of fan discussion about the next Panthers captain is an understatement. While many are calling for long-time Panther Stephen Weiss or returned former Panther Ed Jovanovski to be the new captain, there has been a lot less discussion of another likely candidate: defenseman Brian Campbell. The press has had their fun sniping at Dale Tallon for giving Campbell his rather sizeable contract several years ago and for acquiring it again for his new team, but they conveniently forget that teams were lining up to overpay Campbell the summer after his contract with the Sabres expired. At the time, the Sabres had money problems and several of their best players had expiring contracts. Knowing they couldn't keep everyone, the Sabres traded Campbell to the Sharks and tried to re-sign co-captains Daniel Briere and Chris Drury. They lost out on all three as Briere and Drury went for the big payday elsewhere. The Flyers paid Briere almost as much as Tallon paid Campbell and, in an even more criticized move, the Rangers overpaid Drury. That contract was bought out this summer.
Although he missed several games the last two seasons and had his worst post-lockout season last year for the Blackhawks, Campbell is usually good for around 40 to 50 points and will fill both the offense and leadership hole left by the trade of Bryan McCabe. Since the lockout, the only Panthers defensemen to have 40 point seasons were Jay Bouwmeester (2005-2006, 2006-2007, 2008-2009) and McCabe (2009-2010). Campbell ably replaces the offensive output from the defense that we've been missing since Jay Bouwmeester left but without Bouw's defensive lapses.
Campbell is also a recognized leader. Tallon wanted Campbell on his team for the same reasons he signed him to the Blackhawks: talent, leadership and character. While the Canadian press were snickering about Tallon overpaying the guys lining up to sign with the Panthers this summer, almost every one of those players were saying that Campbell was a large part of the reason they were signing up. Players took notice of someone of Campbell's stature agreeing to waive his no-trade clause and come to a team like the Panthers, who have a long history of struggling. It's one thing for a respected GM like Tallon to say he has a plan to turn the team around. It's quite another to convince a high-profile player to be a part of that plan. While it's likely that not all of the players signed this summer will play out their deals here, expect that Campbell will, and not because of his high price tag. He will be a big part of the changing of this team's fortunes, both on the ice and off.
There has been some criticism of Tallon's "blueprint" as merely having a team that was bad enough that he was able to draft Jonathan Toews and Patrick Kane, but this overlooks the other moves he made at the same time, including signing prized free agent Campbell and getting talented young players in trades, including Kris Versteeg from the Bruins and Patrick Sharp from the Flyers. Again, one of the first big moves that Tallon has made is acquiring Campbell. There are many reasons for the Blackhawks success in winning the Stanley Cup a few seasons ago, and Campbell is a big one of those reasons.
Which player on the Panthers will make the biggest difference this season?
Brian Campbell (52 votes)
David Booth (10 votes)
Ed Jovanovski (1 vote)
Erik Gudbranson (4 votes)
Stephen Weiss (2 votes)
Tomas Fleischmann (11 votes)
Kris Versteeg (17 votes)
Dmitri Kulikov (1 vote)
Scotty Upshall (2 votes)
Jose Theodore (6 votes)
Another Player (1 vote)
107 total votes