Pelts out, McLean in. Your take?

OK, we're all upset over losing Pelts to a viscious act, er, an unavoidable accident. Word on the street has Brett McLean being slotted into #18's spot, now that Kreps is back. Question: Does McLean score a point tonight?

Yes: he plays well and bolsters the line4
No: he bombs and breaks the confidence of 2/3ds of the "CPR" line2